QHIN and HTI-1 Announcements Signal New Era of US Healthcare Data Exchange
Published: January 10, 2024
Cranfield, UK, 10/01/24 – In mid-December 2023, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) made several announcements promoting the development of health information exchanges (HIE).
The first was to officially unveil the first five vendors that can immediately begin exchanging data under the Trusted Exchange Framework and Common Agreement (TEFCA), a nationwide interoperability framework. The vendors, officially designated as the first cohort of Qualified Health Information Networks (QHINs), are:
- eHealth Exchange
- Epic Nexus (subsidiary of Epic Systems)
- Health Gorilla
Secondly, the final ruling of HTI-1 (Health Data, Technology, and Interoperability: Certification Program Updates, Algorithm Transparency, and Information Sharing) was announced. This includes advancements related to interoperability, transparency and greater support for access and exchange of health information.
The Signify View
As analysed in this recent SPI Digital Health Insight, the QHIN concept and its various implications is the result of legislative measures in the US, chiefly the 21st Century Cures Act. This act specifically called for the establishment of a TEFCA whereby, through a network of federally-designated QHINs, healthcare organisations could easily connect and exchange health information securely across the US.
Back in 2019, the non-profit Sequoia Project was selected by the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) as the Recognised Coordinating Entity (RCE) to support TEFCA’s implementation. It had been accepting applications for the first candidate QHINs since 2022, and last month made its decision to officially designate the first cohort of five QHINs.
How will Data Exchange Work Under TEFCA?
Source: The Sequoia Project, User’s Guide to the Trusted Exchange Framework and Common Agreement
QHINs to Eventually Replace HINs?
At its core, the legislation supporting the creation of QHINs aims to break down the information silos that persist US healthcare systems. The 2009 Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) & Meaningful Use Act intended to address this problem by financially incentivising providers to rapidly implement (non-standardised) EHRs. But the more successful EHR vendors realised that it would be better (for them) if their systems were unable to ‘talk’ to other EHR platforms, so providers would be obliged to buy their EHR. This created a siloed system dominated by a select few players.
CommonWell Health Alliance, Carequality and eHealth Exchange are the original national Health Information Networks (HINs) and together they have access to the records of more than 90% of the country’s population. They have been described as the HIEs of HIEs, but although there is some overlap between all three, information exchange between them is anything but smooth.
A major advantage of the new QHINs versus the HINs, however, is that a member organisation of one QHIN will automatically be plugged into all five of the newly qualified TEFCA vendors, which covers the entire care system. Each QHIN connects participants and sub participants. The national HINs stipulate that, unless an HIE specifically opts out, it will automatically be part of a QHIN.
There are currently six authorized Exchange Purposes under the TEFCA agreement: Treatment, Public Health, Payment, Government Benefits Determinations, Health Care Operations, and Individual Access Services. The expectation is for additional Exchange Purposes to be added over time.
CommonWell Health Alliance and Kno2, listed within the original six candidate QHINs, were notable absentees from the designated QHINs. Both contenders, however, will feel confident of receiving QHIN status in the first half of this year. Given that CommonWell agreed a September 2023 partnership with ELLKAY to become its new technical service provider, the settling in period is most likely a key factor behind its absence. Meanwhile, Kno2’s QHIN remains on track for early 2024, according to its published website timeline. Additionally, Surescripts and eClinicalWorks announced their QHIN intentions, in April and December 2023, respectively.
While the newly designated QHINs signal a new era of information sharing, it will be some time before they begin to deliver real benefits. It is not mandatory for an organisation to join a QHIN and those that are already partnering with the incumbent HINs will need compelling reasons to switch to another QHIN.
QHINs will be effective only when they have a critical mass of partners with a critical mass of data to be shared. Essentially, the more users a network has, the better information sharing will be. In May, Epic announced the first cohort of 20 health system joining its QHIN, including major health systems such as Mayo Clinic and Mount Sinai. eHealth Exchange revealed in August that 12 US healthcare organisations would be the initial participants in its QHIN, including larger tier 1 and tier 2 players. Health Gorilla announced in October that 17 US organizations had committed to joining its QHIN, although its partner list predominantly included tier-2 and tier-3 vendors.
A member of one QHIN automatically confers connectivity to other QHINs. But given that organisations are free to choose which QHIN to partner with, familiarity will play a huge role in members’ decision making. For example, most health systems in the US use Epic’s EHRs and therefore already have deep connections to Carequality. Epic will be hoping that the majority of the 2,000 hospitals and 600,000 clinicians nationally using Epic’s interoperability tools will participate. As of December 2023, 84 health systems representing 498 hospitals and 11,711 clinics had opted in. In the case of eHealth Exchange, organisations who are already partners will by default become partners in the new QHIN unless they opt out, and this will therefore limit migration.
Another significant element of the Cures Act helping to eliminate HIE barriers is the anti-information blocking element. In September 2023, the policy was reinforced with the introduction of penalties of $1M per violation for any interference with access to, exchange and use of electronic health information (unless the information is not private, secure or invisible). Two months later, the HSS released a proposed rule to compliment the above penalties, with disincentives for healthcare providers found guilty of information blocking. This would impact reimbursement, scoring, and participation, respectively, under three Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) programs; the Medicare Promoting Interoperability Program (for hospitals), the Promoting Interoperability performance category of the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS, for ambulatory providers), and the Medicare Shared Savings Program (for Accountable Care Organisations – ACOs).
The HTI-1 rule, initially proposed in April 2023 and finalised last month, includes further revisions to information blocking definitions and adds a new exception for TEFCA.
Also of note within the ruling include the new regulatory requirement for healthcare related AI and algorithms to be transparent, safe, and help eliminate existing health disparities without creating new ones. US Core Data for Interoperability (USCDI) Version 3 has been unveiled as the new baseline standard within the ONC Health IT Certification Program. Lastly, developers of certified health IT will be required to report certain interoperability metrics as part of their participation in the Certification Program.
Despite the unprecedented opportunities for information exchange being promoted by TEFCA, the move to QHINs has some high-profile critics. Former ONC National Coordinator Don Rucker suggested that TEFCA is built on outdated data exchange technology that will prevent the initiative from being useful. Despite the need to overcome such obstacles, Signify Research predicts that, over time, HINs will eventually convert fully to QHINs, offering incentives such as FHIR at QHIN level to eventually persuade enough stakeholders to move to QHIN.
There are also concerns from healthcare providers relating to several proposed HTI-1 compliance deadlines required to be met by the end of this year. Less than half of healthcare providers are currently in a position to comply with the interoperability rules set in the Cures Act. To comply with FHIR standards, vendors will need to allocate substantial resources to their solutions. In 2024, some will inevitably fail.
The Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) has this week pushed back on the information blocking disincentives, suggesting that noncompliant providers require greater technical support to protect privacy and security if they are to ensure interoperability. Expect similar from hospitals and clinician groups this year on plans to enforce these data blocking rules in such aggressive timescales. With Medicare reimbursement struggling to keep up with inflation and providers’ operational costs, it could ultimately discourage participation in value-based care programs.
TEFCA will take time to progress and it remains to be seen how effectively QHINs will drive HIE developments. But ultimately last month’s announcements are an important step in driving national baseline standards for clinical data sharing and improving access to health information. As more organisations come on board, TEFCA has the potential to truly mark a new era of interoperability and health data exchange, supporting the national interoperability frameworks’ aim of enhancing clinical decision making, improving patient outcomes and lowering healthcare provider costs.
The above analysis is a summary of some of the trends assessed by Signify Research in its upcoming Health Information Exchange – World – 2024 market report. It provides a data-centric and global outlook of the HIE market by implementation type (i.e. National, State-wide, System-wide, Hospital-specific) and data architecture models (i.e. Centralised, De-centralised/Federated, Hybrid). The report blends primary data collected from in-depth interviews with healthcare professionals and technology vendors, to provide a balanced and objective view of the market.
About Arun Gill
Arun joined Signify Research in 2019 as part of the Digital Health team focusing on EHR/EMR, integrated care technology and telehealth. He brings with him 10 years’ experience as a Senior Market Analyst covering the consumer tech and imaging industry with Futuresource Consulting and NetGrowth Consultants.
About the Digital Health Team
Signify Research’s Digital Health team provides market intelligence and detailed insights on numerous digital health markets. Our areas of coverage include electronic medical records, telehealth & virtual care, remote patient monitoring, high-acuity clinical information systems, patient engagement IT, health information exchanges and integrated care & value-based care IT. Our reports provide a data-centric and global outlook of each market with granular country-level insights. Our research process blends primary data collected from in-depth interviews with healthcare professionals and technology vendors, to provide a balanced and objective view of the market.
About Signify Research
Signify Research provides healthtech market intelligence powered by data that you can trust. We blend insights collected from in-depth interviews with technology vendors and healthcare professionals with sales data reported to us by leading vendors to provide a complete and balanced view of the market trends. Our coverage areas are Medical Imaging, Clinical Care, Digital Health, Diagnostic and Lifesciences and Healthcare IT.
Clients worldwide rely on direct access to our expert Analysts for their opinions on the latest market trends and developments. Our market analysis reports and subscriptions provide data-driven insights which business leaders use to guide strategic decisions. We also offer custom research services for clients who need information that can’t be obtained from our off-the-shelf research products or who require market intelligence tailored to their specific needs.
Share on LinkedIn
Health Information ExchangePublication Date February 2024
Health Information Exchange
This is a proposal for a new Market Report on the global market for Health Information Exchange, to be published in February 2024.
Find out more